How to Get Over Religious Trauma (Even If You Left Years Ago)

You’ve left the church. You’ve unpacked your beliefs. Maybe you even bought the sassy tarot deck.

But despite your deconstruction, you're still feeling stuck. The church trauma lingers. Your body tenses during conflict. Shame shows up in the bedroom. And that voice in your head? It still sounds suspiciously like your old youth pastor.

You’re not alone. Religious trauma runs deep—and it doesn’t go away just because you’ve switched belief systems or can finally say “masturbation” out loud without flinching.

Let’s break down four sneaky reasons why you’re still feeling stuck, even after leaving harmful religious systems. And more importantly, let’s talk about how to actually start healing.

Reason #1 – You Left the Beliefs—But Your Body Still Remembers

You think you’re over it. But if you’re still triggered by words like “obedience,” “submission,” or “God’s timing,” your nervous system has other ideas.

Religious trauma wires your body to fear freedom, mistrust pleasure, and associate shame with visibility. This isn’t just a mindset issue. It’s a trauma response. For many, the trauma is stored not just in memory but in the body itself—a phenomenon well-documented in trauma research (van der Kolk, 2014).

Religious Trauma Syndrome (RTS) mirrors symptoms of complex PTSD: chronic shame, relationship struggles, spiritual confusion, and emotional dysregulation (Ward, 2011; Delaney, 2020). These symptoms don't always show up right away. Sometimes they appear years later—when you're finally in a safer environment to process.

Healing starts when your body feels safe—not just when your brain thinks it should. Somatic practices like breathwork, grounding techniques, and even dancing to music that feels freeing can begin to gently unwind those old patterns.

Reason #2 – Church Trauma *Is* Trauma (Even If It Doesn’t “Look” Like It)

You were taught trauma had to involve violence or war. But church trauma? That’s just “conviction,” right?

Nope.

Spiritual trauma can look like:
- Feeling punished for trusting your body
- Fear of questioning authority
- Chronic shame around sex and identity
- Emotional repression or numbness
- Losing your sense of self

For many who grew up in purity culture or high-control churches, everything from your thoughts to your clothing to your sexuality was under scrutiny. You were praised for being “pure,” “modest,” and “obedient”—and punished for being curious, assertive, or emotionally expressive.

“Trauma is anything too much, too soon, too fast, for too long.” — Dr. Gabor Maté

That means coercive purity teachings, threats of hell, and authoritarian messaging? Yep—they count.

Church trauma often creates an invisible cage that shapes how you see yourself, others, and the divine—even long after you've walked away. But once you name it, you can start to disarm it.

You don’t have to prove your pain for it to be valid.

Reason #3 – You’re Still Holding Onto the “Skinny Jeans” Version of Faith

Ever kept jeans that don’t fit anymore—just in case?

That’s what holding onto an old version of your faith can feel like. Whether it’s guilt, grief, or fear of being “bad,” you may still feel pressure to squeeze yourself into something you’ve clearly outgrown.

Even if you’ve mentally deconstructed, your body might still feel like you’re “doing it wrong” just for evolving. You might find yourself trying to explain or justify your beliefs, or avoiding conversations that could lead to conflict. That’s normal. That’s protective conditioning.

Healing means mourning what didn’t serve you. Buying new jeans. Letting your 🍑 breathe.

It also means embracing the awkward, wobbly parts of faith reconstruction—trying new rituals, exploring different beliefs, or even admitting you’re not sure what you believe right now. That uncertainty isn’t failure. It’s freedom.

Reason #4 –It’s a Delayed Trauma Response (Totally Normal)

One of the trickiest things about religious trauma is that it often shows up after you leave.

Why? Because you weren’t allowed to process while you were in it. Questioning the system was dangerous. Asking for help? Even worse.

Delayed trauma is common in survivors of high-control systems (Herman, 1992). Your symptoms aren’t backsliding—they’re a sign that your body finally feels safe enough to start healing.

Some signs of delayed trauma response include:
- Panic attacks you can’t explain
- Trouble setting or enforcing boundaries
- Feeling emotionally numb or detached from joy
- Unexpected anger or grief resurfacing in relationships

Now’s the time to:
- Explore somatic healing tools like vagus nerve activation, orienting, or bilateral stimulation
- Practice nervous system regulation with breathwork, cold exposure, or self-holding exercises
- Seek support from trauma-informed therapists who understand spiritual abuse

You don’t have to go through this alone. Healing can feel heavy—but it doesn’t have to be lonely.

What Healing Actually Looks Like

Here’s what healing does not require:
- Forcing yourself to go back to church
- Forgiving people before you’re ready
- Accepting spiritual gaslighting as “just someone’s opinion”
- Minimizing how bad it actually was

Here’s what healing might include:
- Letting yourself feel the anger you were taught to fear
- Sitting with your grief—not to dwell, but to witness it
- Learning to trust your "gut" when it used to be called "rebellion"
- Practicing self-compassion instead of religious self-judgment
- Creating rituals that feel meaningful—even if they’re just for you

You might find that healing doesn't look like one big breakthrough moment. It often looks like subtle changes:
- You stop apologizing for existing.
- You say “no” and don’t spiral afterward.
- You wear what feels good—not what someone else told you is "pure."
- You catch yourself being kind to the parts of you you used to shame.

“Healing isn’t about becoming who you were before the trauma. It’s about becoming who you were meant to be in the absence of it.” — Unknown

You may never "go back to normal"—because that version of normal was never safe. But you can build a new normal grounded in safety, pleasure, and truth.

A Quick Personal Note

There was a time I *desperately* wanted to be in a romantic relationship. I had done the work—I’d deconstructed, named the shame, deleted the dating purity checklist. Mentally, I was ready.

But every time physical intimacy came into the picture, my body would shut down. Not metaphorically—*literally*. Muscles tightened. Breath stopped. I’d go stiff, frozen. The other person would reach out, and I’d recoil like I was being touched by sin itself.

The most frustrating part? I *didn’t even believe that anymore*. I wasn’t scared of sex. I was scared of my conditioning. And it was keeping me from the very thing I wanted most: connection, romance, love.

That moment cracked something open. I realized I had dismantled the theology, but my nervous system hadn’t gotten the memo.

Now, I approach those moments with a lot more compassion. My body wasn’t betraying me—it was protecting me. And once I started working with it instead of against it, everything started to shift.

If any part of that resonates with you—you're not broken. You're healing.

Ready to Flip Religious Trauma the Bird? 🖕

If you’re tired of doing it alone—or feeling like you should already be “over it”—you’re not wrong for needing support.

Safe Talk Therapy helps millennials heal from:
- Religious trauma and spiritual abuse
- Purity culture and sexual shame
- Church hurt and institutional betrayal
- Complex trauma that started in sacred spaces

We integrate nervous system regulation, trauma-informed therapy, and real conversations (no spiritual bypassing here) to help you:
- Reconnect with your body and intuition
- Reclaim joy, pleasure, and autonomy
- Build boundaries without guilt
- Rewrite your story—on your terms

Whether you need a space to cry, cuss, question, or reconstruct—we’ve got you.

---

🎯 Book a free 15-minute consultation

This is a zero-pressure zone. 
No purity tests. No church speak. No shame.

Just a space to see if we’re a good fit for your healing journey.

You've already done the hardest part—leaving. 
Now it's time to heal.